Authors' Matters by ALCS
Authors' Matters is a podcast by the Authors’ Licensing and Collecting Society (ALCS) where we talk to writers from across the profession about how they earn their living, or at least try to. From copyright to contracts, we’ll also talk about issues that make the writing living easier or more difficult.
Authors' Matters by ALCS
S5 Ep3: A tribute to Maureen Duffy
The great Maureen Duffy, novelist, poet, playwright, and non-fiction writer, sadly died in May 2026. In this episode we speak to three people who knew Maureen professionally and personally and they share great insight into her life, her work and her activism, particularly all she did for authors' rights including the founding of ALCS.
Host Caroline Sanderson is joined by writer Stella Duffy, King's Professor Lawrence Warner and Kevin Fitzgerald, IAF Chair.
In this episode of Authors Matters, we pay tribute to Maureen Duffy, co-founder and honorary president of ALCS, who died in May at the age of 92. The author of poetry, novels, plays, and biography, Maureen was a tenacious lifelong campaigner, not only for authors' rights, but for the LGBTQ community and for animal rights too. With the help of our three guests, three people for whom Maureen was a beacon, we'll be discussing her life and work, her activism, and her considerable legacy. And we'll be considering Maureen as a person and the qualities that made her such an effective campaigner and colleague. Let me introduce our guests. Dr. Stella Duffy, OBE, no relation, is a writer and psychotherapist. She's the author of novels, short stories and plays, and her first work of nonfiction coming early next year. She's twice won the Stonewall Writer of the Year and twice the Crime Writers Association Short Story Dagger. Kevin Fitzgerald, CMG, is Secretary General of the International Authors Forum, IAF for short, and worked with Maureen Duffy over many years in the arena of authors' rights, both at the IAF and also while a director of the World Intellectual Property Organization. Lawrence Warner is Professor of Medieval English at King's College London, where Maureen Duffy studied as an undergraduate in the 1950s, and she later became a Fellow of King's in 2002. He knew Maureen for many years, and originally they bonded over Piers Ploughman. Welcome to all of you. And I want to start by asking each of you to tell us how you came to know Maureen or became aware of her work as a writer and as an activist. Stella, why don't you start?
SPEAKER_03Well, it wasn't the name. But I came out late 70s. I'm 63. I've known I was gay since my teens, like many of us did. And there was nothing. You know, really, there was nothing. And they certainly weren't lesbian role models. We might have been able to point to, I don't know, some man who was an actor who was maybe rumored to be gay. But because gay men had the law against them, the ones who did come out came out early. So we've got, you know, Quentin Chris, we've got um Wild, but we didn't have women role models. And Maureen was out. Oh God, I want to cry. I can't tell you how important this is. We talk now about queer rights as if things are better, but they're really not. And there are many countries in the world where it's backsliding. Maureen being the first publicly out lesbian on British television was enormous. And the microcosm, which I read very young, and it was very hard because it is a really interesting literary piece of work, just made such a difference to so many of us. But it was published in 1967, wasn't it? Yeah, which I certainly didn't read then, I was three. But it it made such a difference because she was presenting our lives in in their in in their multiplicity. And we've always been talked about as if we're such a cliche. And there was this person who'd lived it, and basically it was also the direct opposite of the nastiness of the killing of Sister George. So as a queer woman, she made a massive difference to me. And as a writer, she's amazing.
SPEAKER_02Well, that's an amazing testament right at the beginning, and that's before we've even got onto the subject of author's rights. Uh, thank you, Lawrence. Um, tell us how you came to know Maureen.
SPEAKER_01I was at an event at King's College London um with Caroline Bergval was presenting, who is a um a great poet and author inspired by medieval literature. And over at Coffee, there was this little old lady, and we had coffee for a minute, and she asked, I was brand new to King's. She asked about me, and I said that I had written about this medieval poem, Pierce Plowman. And she said, Oh, I went to university here in the 1950s. I wrote a play based on Pierce Plowman. My archives are here, you know, it might be in there. And I said, Are you that woman out front whose picture is next to Desmond Tutu? And Lord Wellington? Yes, that's me, Maureen Duffy. And that was the beginning. I went and read that play, uh, Pearson. Um, I ended up writing a big article about Marilyn Robinson and Maureen Duffy, who in many ways are opposites. Marilyn Robinson is a Puritan, self-described Calvinist uh in the States, and Maureen Duffy is a humanist, but they both have this shared adoration of Pierce Plowman and actually a lot of literary things in common too. So I wrote this big article. And in the process of that, I learned that Maureen had written a poem, um, The Missa Humana, Humanist Mass, which her dear friend back in the 60s and 70s had set to music. And she told me that her number one um sadness was that it had never been produced, and that her friend who died, Dolly Collins, died in 1995, had never been able to hear it. And it's a long story which I won't tell, but I was able to get that produced. And Maureen was there, and um, that was one of the most magical nights I've ever had in 2023. Um, and I got to know her very well through the course of all this.
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, amazing testaments to her literary legacy. Um, Kevin, uh, let's move on to authors' rights, which we will talk in a little bit more detail about as we go on. But how did you come to know Maureen?
SPEAKER_00So I've known Maureen for 25 years. Um there's a definite professional strand to that, but that uh converted into a personal strand as well. So we first met when I was chief executive of the UK's copyright licensing agency. So we were collecting a lot of the money which flowed into ALCS. So Maureen and I had had that professional relationship, and it was quite a fun relationship because I was on the side of publishers and authors and visual creators and kind of worked with the government. Um, so I was on the same side, but at the same time, Maureen was constantly needling me to try and push the authors um slightly to the fore, uh, which was fun and really interesting. So, in that professional capacity, we had lunch together um every couple of months for 10 years. Now, I then moved to Geneva, to the United Nations, uh, the World Intellectual Property Organization, as you mentioned. And um, so I was uh working with member states on intellectual property and copyright. So Maureen um was jumping on the plane to come and try and needle me there when I was supposed to be entirely neutral. But the professional relationship was was very positive for both of us. Uh but underneath that we we developed a personal relationship as well. Uh we had some things in common and some some very big differences. Um, but we we met up at social events in in London, Paris, Geneva. She came to my home, and uh so she she was a good personal friend as well. She could be a good needler, couldn't she? Indeed. Very lovingly. It absolutely great class about the way in which she needled.
SPEAKER_02We don't have uh time to go into a detailed sort of biography of Maureen, but I think it's um interesting to touch on her early life and how you maybe think that influenced the writer and campaigner that she became, and how she, you know, be uh became a writer because she was from quite humble working class background, wasn't she? Maybe Lawrence, say something about that.
SPEAKER_01Well, she she her first novel, That's how it was, um, is very autobiographical in many ways. She insisted, and she's totally right, it is a work of art. It was not written as an autobiography, but you can there's no way anyone but Maureen with her background could have written this. And um, I mean, I'll never forget getting to the final sentences. Now, what the hell do I do now? Uh, she was 15 years old. The the narrator there is, I think, 15, just as Maureen was when her when her mother died. She did not know who her father was. Uh, she told me the last time I saw her that she had a few times thought about trying to track him down, um, and that that never succeeded, or she decided it wouldn't be a good idea. But she did cash in, I should say, on her Duffy name by uh going to Dublin and singing folk music and dancing once um and getting away with it that way. She she really had a I love that. But she she grew up um quite working class, she worked very hard to get into university and was very proud of having gone to King's. I would say that it made her very independent and fierce, and that fits with the author's rights very well. I've seen a fair bit of the correspondence in her archives about this, and you can really see how adamant she is.
SPEAKER_03I think growing up without wealth, without privilege, which still, even today, the vast majority of British writers are from middle class or upper middle class backgrounds, it's very standard. I'm the youngest of seven kids from a council of state in South East London. It is different for those of us who do not know what an agent is, who get our books from libraries, who do not know that people like us can become writers. And I really think that's key to her passion for getting writers paid. Because unless you understand how incredibly difficult it is, without, to quote Virginia, a private, you know, a room of one's own and a private income of 500 a year, all very well, but Virginia wasn't giving that to her woman servants. Um, unless you know how hard it is, you don't know how important ALCS and PLR are to us. And she did.
SPEAKER_02Well, I I want to concentrate for the purposes of this episode very much on the author's rights, but I just want to read out a quote from Maureen herself. And this is from, I looked out, this is a sort of celebratory book for ALCS's uh 40 years anniversary. Uh it's actually ALCS's 50 years anniversary next year in uh 2027. And you, Maureen, are still fighting for authors' rights in your ninth decade. What motivates you to keep doing so? I've always been interested in politics, and there's a sort of bloody-mindedness in me that wants to take issues on. It's a continuous battle. As well as authors' rights, I've also been a campaigner for gay rights and animal rights. I feel very strongly that you have to stand up and play your part. Which is, yeah, it's an inspiration for any of us, really.
SPEAKER_03Oh, well, I think it's really important because there is an assumption, partly because the papers will tell you so-and-so got £100,000, or this politician sold a book for millions. The vast majority of writers in Britain do not earn that much. And the need for the Authors Licensing and Collectors Society for PLR is still enormous, not least to acknowledge the work that's gone in.
SPEAKER_02Yes, and I think um it's interesting because I know a lot of authors say that their payments from PLR and from ALCS, obviously, the money is hugely important and crucial, but it's also a recognition, and I feel there's this thread through Maureen's work of wanting, you know, writers to be recognized as professional people, as, and that goes back to what you were saying about how hard it is, but recognizing that-I mean, when you're talking about the needling, Kevin, this is a constant refrain, though, isn't it? You know, writers deserve this, they've earned it.
SPEAKER_00Well, I think that her background is the underpinning of her understanding of this need for a structure for remuneration. If you're brought up in economic deprivation, you're focused for the rest of your life on ensuring that there's some kind of security of income.
SPEAKER_02For those people who may not be very familiar with um Maureen's sort of activism, uh, just to summarize very briefly, she was a co-founder of what was then called the Writer's Action Group with Bridget Brophy and others. Uh, that was founded in 1972. And before we turn to ALCS specifically, we should acknowledge her contribution to establish the principle of public lending right, which I think you touched on, um, Stella. And um uh I remember her talking about speaking at the TUC conference in 1978, feeling completely terrified about doing so. But as a result, public lending right became law in 1979. Uh, and uh we're almost 50 years from the founding of ALCS itself next year. Uh and when I interviewed Maureen in 2022, she said, no one thought we needed it, nobody knew what it was, and we had to invent it out of nothing. And I was really struck again by that, thinking about that's just incredible vision and ambition, isn't it? There was just nothing, nothing existed.
SPEAKER_01And yet it's like writing a poem.
SPEAKER_02Well, there was nothing. And there was a there was a lovely tribute on Front Row when when Maureen died, uh, Joelle Taylor, the writer, saying that she thought about the physical reality of what writers do and how to sustain it. So I find that um I found I find that sort of prescience really interesting. That and maybe that's something that contributed to the fact that she carried on Kevin being such a doubty campaigner for so many years. She was always looking ahead and to future developments and what that might mean.
SPEAKER_00So when ALCS was founded in 1977, it was a bit of a wing and a prayer. It was a bit of we should be doing something, but not entirely sure what we're going to do. And then two years later, after 30 years of campaigning, PLR um came in. So that was almost the first concrete type of licensing uh which took place. Now, PLR, just to put some figures on it, um, generates about 7 million pounds per year for authors in the UK. But ALCS, in its life, has generated 750 million pounds of income.
SPEAKER_02It's a staggering figure, isn't it?
SPEAKER_00From nothing at all. Absolutely extraordinary. And and Maureen was was pretty much the pioneer of that. But it ran all the way through her life. And I mentioned earlier that she was constantly needling me in my various professional capacities. But what's very interesting is even until a couple of years ago, she was traveling to Geneva to talk about artificial intelligence because she knew that this was the next challenge. She and I had gone through digital content, digital platforms, and digital licensing professionally together. But now she wanted to move on to artificial intelligence. And for her, it was partly about the rights, kind of the legal rights, but it was also to ensure that authors were not economically left out of artificial intelligence. So she and I she and I had these interesting conversations about how we can fix that. The answer, by the way, is licensing. Um and we're now starting to work out there are some, there are now some licenses which actually begin to deal with AI. But but she knew that this had to be dealt with, and she spoke in Geneva about this even just a couple of years ago.
SPEAKER_03Could I add something about the activism? I think it's to do with otherness, and I think this with a psychotherapeutic hat on. I think that if you are from other, so she's gay, she's born out of wedlock at a time when those things really mattered, born, grew up poor, as you say, didn't know her father because he left when she was, what, two? And her mother died when she was fifteen. I think you left overnight. So she's well outside what is the standard and the norm. And she's a woman at a time when women, even now, are still not given the same space in broadsheets when they're literary writers as the men are. So she's coming from an outside perspective. And I think there is something really important around the activism that is an outsider is actually probably better at noticing what needs changing to be more inclusive than someone who is in the inside, however willing they are to open up, they're still going to be from the inside. If you're already outside, and it is something I feel very personally, very strongly, if you're already outside, you're going to see it more clearly. And she did so for decades.
SPEAKER_00You know, that's but that there's there's a really you've used the word outsider and insider. Um, I would also call her an infiltrator.
SPEAKER_03Yes. Great, great, great term.
SPEAKER_00This this is really interesting because she did have the outside perspective, obviously. We've we've stated that quite clearly. But she operated inside. And she was a very smooth operator. I don't know if you attended House of Commons or House of Lords events with her, but she sidled up to people and she cornered them. She also spoke into the the microphone to address the assembled members of the houses. Um and I remember one of the events, it was on the terrace of the House of Commons, and little Maureen stood up on the microphone, and she had this huge smile on her face, and she said, My lords, ladies, and gentlemen. And then she chuckled and said, I've always wanted to say that. So she really got everybody's attention, but she was a coming back to the point, um, she was a really shrewd operator, and she knew that as an outsider with outside observations and causes, you could only make progress from the inside. And she did that really well.
SPEAKER_03Infiltrator is a fantastic term. But I think this shows up in her writing as well. The angle on characters is the angle that you get if you if you're writing characters that don't quite fit. And that gives us so much, as readers, so much more access. I mean, it shines out in The Orpheus Trail, in Alchemy, in Capital in particular. Characters that don't quite fit in are often narrators or protagonists that we follow through. And I think that's part of that as well. They don't fit, but they're inside, giving us a different angle. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I think one thing that struck me as well, um, Kevin, actually, is the is the sheer scope of her remit by by later life, you know, in terms of I I mentioned there speaking to the TUC Congress back in the day on PLR. But um, we're talking on a global stage, really, in terms of authors' rights, and increasingly having to look at a lot of these issues globally. So on the European level, as we talked about, but also on a sort of global level, with representatives from all over the world, actually. So, you know, finding your voice and being able to speak to that broader kind of remit is also striking to me, I think.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. So at WIPO, the World Intellectual Property Organization, she would push the button and make her interventions and speak to 200 member states. That was one thing that she did very well. On behalf of authors, I'm telling you this. But she was also very clever because the Director General of the organization, who had global stature, met presidents, prime ministers, and the like, sat in the top of his ivory tower, physically, not ivory, but tower, top of. Um, and little Maureen would turn up with one of her latest books for him. And every time she came, she had a little gift for him, and it was one of her books signed to the Director General, and she'd come up and knock on the door, and if he was available, she'd go in and give it to him, and if not, leave it with one of the secretaries. But he was telling me that Maureen was doing this, and he chuckled with delight as well, because every time one of these committees was coming up, he knew he was going to get another book from Maureen. And it was very, very clever of her.
SPEAKER_01That's why she wrote so much.
SPEAKER_00But it was a subtle way of influencing somebody.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00She was really well known by that guy.
SPEAKER_02I don't think we can overstate the amount of time and energy that has, you know, been put in by Maureen Duffy over decades in these different forums. Um and I I was thinking about when you were talking about uh now how we're grappling with uh the whole issue of AI and authors' rights, you know, so much has changed since those early days where photocopying was just coming in, which was one of the spurs for thinking about founding what became ALCS. But the kind of essential mantra of the writers' action group, no use without payment, is still the mantra, really, isn't it? That hasn't changed.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely, yes. Um and licensing has changed over the years. It was photocopying, then it was digital copying, and it's just beginning to move into um artificial intelligence. But that there's a whole bunch of other things going on around the world. So an interesting development which I did mention to Maureen, but she wasn't able to take forward, is the secondary sale of books. So, like secondhand books being sold. And she was she was delighted. To hear that this was something which was just beginning to get thought of. So she she maintained an interest in that.
SPEAKER_02Well, let's think about what will be Maureen Duffy's enduring legacy. Lawrence, in the tribute to Maureen Duffy on the King's College website, you write, it might be easier to describe what Maureen Duffy hasn't done over her long career than to list her many accomplishments, which I think we've we've touched on here. The world was a much better place for Maurey, great citizen and scribe of London. Why did you describe her thus?
SPEAKER_01It's an easy out, and it's true. Those are the two things that she really, as an author, she saw herself, I think she saw herself primarily as a poet. She was most prolific as a novelist. She was a biographer. She was an essayist. One of one thing that she and I enjoyed figuring out was that I read her nonfiction book about her ancestry, her maternal ancestry uh in Essex. Um and on page at the time I should say, I was reading her books and skimming through sometimes appropriately to find any place where she might mention Piers Ploughman or Langlin because Langland's the author of Piers Ploughman, because it was a lot. And she didn't remember it all. She couldn't tell me where to look, really. And I spotted Warner, you know, so-and-so Warner on page 93. And looking into it, I realized this was my ancestor as well. This was 10 generations ago up in Essex. And so we and the families were connected. Um, so we probably were 11th cousins. We had to chuckle over that. She even knew this really well. And in fact, in the archives, I went to look more into the um materials behind this book. It's called um Inherit the Earth. And uh for the meek is still inherit the earth, the outsider idea again. And actually, in the archives are kind of a mess because it all just comes from her attic. Next to the Kings, they do the best to have at least a finding aid. And the finding aid here said, um, okay, letters concerning that book. And I saw fascinating letters. This was when genealogy was getting big. Who would think of Maureen Duffy as one of the main genealogy gurus as well? But she was. Next to the files with the correspondence that was generated by Inherit the Earth was a file that said photographs from a production of rights. And I opened it. It was not a photo. There were people who weren't women, and there was not a toilet block. And I realized actually that these were photographs of the production of the very play that I was writing on, the one that was Pearson, based on Pierce Plowman, which were totally misfiled. Uh that's just kind of an aside. This is the way that Maureen kind of as a phenomenon works. You think you might be um getting to know her genealogical writing, which is a one-off as it is, and then you find yourself finding archival treasures. This is Ewan Duff, again, not quite related, but Ewan Duff is a great photographer who did the covers of two of her early novels. He took these photographs. I was able to publish them with his permission and Maureen's and King's College, London's in um the yearbook of Langland studies. There were black folks on a stage. She talked to me about how proud she was to be representing um Caribbeans and black people on stage in the 50s. Um, no one else is doing this. The yearbook of Langland Studies does not have very much about black folks, I'll say. I was very proud to be able to publish this picture there. So when I started by talking here about how she did everything, this is just one little narration of how it worked. Uh, the world's a better place with her. She is still here, is the other thing I'll say about that. I mean, it's very sad that she's that she's died. But um uh her impact is so huge literarily. For us English teachers, it's it's a wonderful gift. But um I'm loving hearing so much about the um the author's rights and the Lindy rights and things like that. I know about it. There's a lot of correspondence about that too, I'll say, um, in the archives. There's so much waiting to be found.
SPEAKER_02There's so many facets to this. And Stella, I was thinking about you as a writer. You know that absolutely the challenges of of being a writer, establishing yourself as a writer, but also keeping on writing, which was uh I I know Maureen once said to me that is almost the biggest challenge. And you've written also across many genres. Um, all writers owe her a huge debt, don't they? Um perhaps a special um, you know, mention for queer writers. What what do you feel will be Maureen Duffy's legacy?
SPEAKER_03I did an event um at Pilari, Paul Burston's queer um literary salon, a few years ago now. I mean, maybe 10 even with Maureen. And what was so lovely, because that that gig gets a lot of young people, a lot of young writers coming along, and then a whole bunch of us who middle age and early old age. And Maureen sat there giving forth, but so kindly. See, I I don't know that people who didn't meet her in life would know how generous she was, as well as needling, I'm absolutely, and I'm glad and I'm grateful for it. But the generosity of inclusion, and I think that that is really important to note in terms of her legacy. I'd also say I get really frustrated when people don't talk about what a great actual just writer she was. And if anyone ever asks me about a favourite novel or a London novel, I always say capital, because for my money, and there are and I love a London novel, I've written a bunch myself, but there is nothing as good as Capital. It is a stunning novel. And she, for all that she's done for all of us, for my queer community, for the writing community, I do really want her to be remembered as a brilliant writer as well.
SPEAKER_02Well, very much um thinking about this, this episode has made me really want to read more of Maureen Caffey's work. Yeah, Capital, that's on the list. Uh, I have um, and I loved her biography of Afro Ben. I mean, I had no idea that there was such a female figure, you know, in those times. And her England history book. I mean, she's so erudite.
SPEAKER_01My son quoted that in his university application. Oh, fantastic.
SPEAKER_02There's so many facets to this, it's absolutely fascinating. Um, Kevin, I'd think maybe we'd finish on uh you touched there, Stella, on the generosity of her character, maybe say something about what kind of person she was and how that contributed to this sort of extraordinary body of work across so much.
SPEAKER_00Uh generosity I I recognize, but I'd also observe bravery. And her bravery um was something. But I I did want to touch on her legacy as well. Um, so I think her legacy was twofold. Firstly, it was economic inclusion, and and we've touched on that with the licensing. She viewed authors as being an essential link in the economic value chain of creativity, and she wanted them to be rewarded for that so they could continue to contribute. So that I think was her first legacy, and then her second legacy, I think, was social inclusion. And and this is really important. Social inclusion for everybody. So her London trilogy talked about Afro-Caribbeans, it talked about gays through the lens of Dante, and I think her point was you cannot have one single character as a Londoner. It's like everybody's included in the character of being a Londoner. And um I was looking through my my little library at home uh and the Maureen Duffy works, um, and I just spotted this one. This uh this one is is my favourite one because of the content, it's in times like these. But because I opened it to have a quick look through, um, I actually noticed, and this goes back to the generosity, for Kevin, Happy Birthday, Love Maureen, Maureen Duffy, London 2014. Um, so that's part of the generosity, but the legacy. So this is also about um social inclusion. I mean, in times like these, talks about the Scottish referendum, um, she predicts Scottish independence, very importantly, she predicts Brexit and paints the most awful picture of the economic deprivation arising from Brexit and the societal discord arising from Brexit. And I think the point of this and the London trilogy is if you go towards tribalism and exclusion, everybody loses. If you go towards valuing everybody and including everybody, then everybody wins. And as a kind of social inclusion motif, I think that's fantastic.
SPEAKER_01Can I add to that that her favorite work, the epigraph of that, is a line that shows up throughout, and and that um when at this concert, based on her um Missa Humana, she said, what she had in mind in the Missa Humana was inclusion, a fair fellow full of folk, fondi there between the rich and the poor, everybody. It's this vision of unanimity, of humanity altogether, the rich, the poor. And that was always from mantra in writing as well. This social inclusion that you talk about, Kevin. I had no idea that she had that in mind with this poem that she that I had already published my article about Pierce Plumman, but she said Pierce Ploughman and that vision of everyone together on this fair field full of folk was what drove her to write this humanist mass as well. Beautiful.
SPEAKER_02Thank you all so much. I I I love in a way that we finished on Maureen's work because I'm aware of a writer who gave so much time and energy to so many other causes, and you part of me thinks that's time that she could have spent just on her own work and done nothing else. So the fact that her work, you know, will endure and deserves to be read, and I'm certainly going to read more is a great point to finish on. Thank you all so much for speaking so beautifully, and uh it's been so illuminating hearing about aspects of her life and career that uh I didn't know about. Thank you all so much for contributing to this tribute to the late great Maureen Duffy.
SPEAKER_01It's an honor. Thank you.